Sunday’s pro-Palestine march of 100,000 or more in the drenching rain over the Sydney Harbour Bridge crystallised a moment in history for Australia and the watching world. To be caught in such a moment is exhilarating, shocking, disturbing and/or discombobulating, depending on where you sit.
The Foreign Affairs Minister
Penny Wong appeared to grapple with all of it in real time on the ABC’s 7.30 last night:
“First, I want to say that was an extraordinary march and I think it demonstrates what we all feel. I know that Australians are feeling distressed, angry, upset, really horrified by what they’re seeing in Gaza. I certainly share that distress, so do ministers in the government, and I know from my engagement with the Australian community, the extent to which this has become an issue that is really, really widespread across the Australian community, and I think the march demonstrated that.”
The humanitarian crisis in Gaza has been the tipping point, in particular starvation and Israel’s failure to provide aid safely and effectively. As The Politics wrote yesterday, the distribution of aid is under the control of an organisation run by a prominent US evangelical Christian, Pastor Johnnie Moore Jr.
Wong added:
“It is not just a breach of international humanitarian law. It’s a breach of our common humanity and it can’t be countenanced. I think it is impossible to justify withholding aid from women and children. And I think you have seen across the Australian community, people from very different perspectives make the same point.”
Extraordinarily, Wong found it impossible to say whether Israel wants peace in Gaza.
Sarah Ferguson: Does Israel want peace in Gaza?
Wong: Well, you can’t see into people’s hearts and minds, can you?
Ferguson: What’s your interpretation?
Wong: Well, no, what I would say is Israel has a right to security, and I would argue that the only pathway, long term, to peace and security is two states. That means a ceasefire, release of hostages and aid to flow and progress towards a two-state solution.
Today Wong warned the failure of the international community to help form a two-state solution through ending the war in Gaza may mean “there is no Palestine left to recognise”.
The NSW Premier
Chris Minns opposed the bridge march and has faced internal party criticism. He, too, has been caught in the shifting currents of the Israel/Hamas conflict. This is how he explained his position yesterday:
“I’ve said repeatedly that the circumstances relating to civilians, particularly children in Palestine, is a massive, massive concern for me as much as anybody else. We’re effectively two years [on] from October 7, 2023. The war continues. It shows no sign of stopping. The intervention from the Israeli government in relation to humanitarian aid and care has been disastrous for the population in Gaza.”
He went on:
“But I have to say, like many people, I think a lot of people who were at the bridge as well, you can hold many views at the same time. You can be appalled by Hamas. You can be terrified and shocked by the hostage-taking. You can see the situation where innocent people were slaughtered in southern Israel and at the same time hold the view that the IDF’s actions in bombing hospitals or stopping humanitarian aid is a massive concern as a human being, and like most people I suspect in the world, I’ve got both of those views.”
And then:
“And the only people that have a 100% view one way or the other — where they don’t acknowledge atrocities committed against Israelis or they don’t acknowledge atrocities and starvation committed against Palestinians — are the people that would park their humanity at the door in favour of one side or the other. I suspect like millions of people I’ve got mixed views on it.”
Former Israeli defence and security officials
In Israel, 19 former heads of Shin Bet, Mossad, military intelligence and the police have issued a joint video message calling on Benjamin Netanyahu to end the war in Gaza. Here in translation is some of what they said:
“We are on the precipice of defeat.”
“This war started as a just war. It was a defensive war. But once we achieved all its military objectives, once we achieved a brilliant military victory against all our enemies, this war stopped being a just war.”
“This is leading the state of Israel to the loss of its security and its identity.”
“We are much more than a year past the point where we could have ended the war with a sufficient operational achievement. We are now mostly offsetting losses.”
“We have buried the achievements. I don’t know any army that defeated a guerilla enemy through war. We are currently in a static situation in Gaza. No matter how good an army is, a war with no political goal is a war of defeat.”
Israeli Prime Minister
Meanwhile, Netanyahu has reportedly decided on full occupation of the Gaza Strip and has told the head of the IDF that if he didn’t agree, he should resign.










0 Comments