Senator Fatima Payman has had a brilliant idea: to save politics she wants to take the politics out of politics. She has a brand: she is principled. All power to her — but she should be ready for the machine to bite back once the professionals get to work.
The Western Australia senator, late of the Labor Party, has been in the belly of the political beast and clearly didn’t like what she saw. Her breaking point was the Albanese government’s policy on Israel and Gaza — she couldn’t reconcile it with her sense of right and wrong. So she has left the machine with little more than the clothes on her back and a spot in the Senate (which Labor wants back).
Her new party has a name: Australia’s Voice. But there’s little else so far. Policy is a work in progress. Her summary position is that she will offer a voice for every Australian who is “disenfranchised” and who is “sick and tired of the duopoly of the major parties”. It has a ring of Statue of Liberty idealism about it: “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”
It would be easy to analyse Payman to death; indeed that work is already underway. One interviewer demanded that the Muslim, veil-wearing senator make a choice: is Hamas a terrorist or a resistance movement? And she has been accused of angering First Nations leaders by using “Voice” in the name. No doubt she will be subjected to the full hypocritical blast of Australia’s political media which castigates politicians for their poor performance while living off the crumbs of the political duopoly, the one Payman (and others) seek to disrupt.
Cogs in the machine
While the light from Payman’s torch still glows, let’s reflect on the human cost of the political machine, particularly to those who live inside it. This week there has been plenty of it on display.
First, there is Albanese himself — or “poor Albo”, an increasingly apt moniker. Poor Albo sputtered badly this week when he blurted out that opposition frontbencher Angus Taylor must have Tourettes given the style and frequency of Taylor’s interjections. It was just one of those horrible “Oh fuck” moments when you realise you’ve just made the evening news for all the wrong reasons. Poor Albo tried to take it back but he was done in. it was a seemingly involuntary utterance which, in a terrible double whammy, is characteristic of the disease itself.
Poor Albo is prone to such lapses — notwithstanding that he is a master of the political machine. Remember his self-described “brain fade” during the 2022 election campaign when he couldn’t instantly recall the RBA’s current cash rate? He even made a sound like a malfunctioning machine when he realised it was an “Oh fuck” moment? (For all that, though, can’t we allow a political leader to have a human moment when under constant pressure?)
As Albanese knows, these moments trigger a pre-programmed set of processes which, AI-like will ultimately lead to one pundit or another declaring that poor Albo’s leadership is under threat. Or might be. (Or would be, except that Bill Shorten is no longer around.) The political machine of course also produces the likes of Opposition Leader Peter Dutton who is poor Albo’s opposite, in all senses of the word. Dutton has internalised the lesson that the best way to prosper in the machine is to strip away all human weakness and humanity (at least when in public.) So the public Dutton can make false accusations without blinking and plough on in the face of the uproar it produces — because the last thing you do is apologise or admit you were wrong like poor Albo did.
Arise Australia’s Donald Trump.
Out of the shadows
To me, the most poignant glimpse of forbidden political humanity this week came courtesy of Attorney-General Mark Dreyfus. Dreyfus is Jewish. For him and others, the anniversary of Hamas’s horrific October 7 attacks has brought out a nightmare mix of emotions which few can truly comprehend. Dreyfus had the grace to acknowledge that this applied to Jews and Palestinians. And despite the darkness he expressed his hope for a better future.
He well and truly dropped the political mask, telling of his family’s direct experience of the Holocaust:
“Six million dead. Within living memory. I am the son and grandson of Holocaust survivors. Australia gave them the home it denied many others. Yet I am asked why I support genocide. Do they not know the pain that question evokes? Maybe they do.”
He called the rise in anti-Semitism in Australia after the Hamas attack “truly shocking”: “Equally shocking has been the reluctance of some on the left to call out Hamas’s behaviour for what it is: an attempt to kill as many Jews as possible and inflict harm every day since.”
He also took aim at what the machine of politics has done:
“Bipartisanship on Israel fractures. The opposition leader says it’s ‘reckless’ to maintain support for a two-state solution. The Greens drum up division inside and outside of parliament. Partisan politics trumps everything in pursuit of a cheap social media post, a new headline, a new donor, a new voter.”
It is remarkable that one of Australia’s most senior politicians felt he needed to keep this to himself for the past 12 months, and that when he opened up the raw pain of it all he did so not in the parliament but via the digital pages of Guardian Australia.
So Payman is right. Politics as it is practised is no place for a human, especially one with principles. But there are plenty of entrenched interests to ensure that that’s how it’s going to stay.
Make sure to send us your feedback and tips via thepoliticsau@protonmail.com










0 Comments