That’s not cricket: Dutton nukes CSIRO’s probity

The Australia v India Test is underway, and the opposition leader could learn from players about how to play the game with class: don’t bad-mouth the umpire when you’re called out.

When the Roy Morgan research house released its annual “trusted brand awards” for 2024, Australia’s national research organisation, the CSIRO, was on the winners’ list for the third year in a row. Hardly surprising, because it prevails despite a febrile political environment where regard for public institutions is an increasingly rare commodity.

It’s old wisdom that trust and confidence in our institutions — which are meant to endure beyond the intermittent spells of power and influence of this or that politician or public servant, or party or faction — is hard won and easily destroyed. So in the current climate it’s no real surprise that the long-established Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation is being accused of:

  • “Considerable and consistent political bias”, by one of the loudest voices from the pile-on within the pro-nuclear lobby;
  • Bowing to the “heavy hand” of the government, by Opposition Leader Peter Dutton, would-be next prime minister;
  • Having been “set up to do the government’s dirty work”, by National Party leader and aspiring deputy PM David Littleproud; 
  • Being “partisan”, by maverick Nationals frontbencher and former deputy PM Barnaby Joyce.

Pie in the Sky

These accusations and other alleged failings are regularly featured in the Murdoch media, including Sky News, which apes its American Fox Network cousins, and which hasn’t seen a science-based institution it doesn’t want to disparage in one way or another. Never mind that the CSIRO’s Most Trusted Brand in Government Services award was in a category that the Roy Morgan researchers acknowledged was “marked by widespread distrust”.

Indeed, they said, the CSIRO was one of only two finalists from a field of 20 to achieve a positive “net trust score”, the other being Medicare. 

So these are vulnerable times for our institutions. It’s a safe bet that if the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA), the nation’s interest rate setter and cost-of-living ultimate villain, were on the Roy Morgan list it would have been in serious trust deficit with battling Australian households. 

So it seems convenient that Dutton likes to hold the independence of the RBA as being sacrosanct, resolutely opposing recent major reforms of Australia’s central bank by the Albanese government, but feels free to pursue and encourage a campaign to undermine the CSIRO. He puts one on a political pedestal, while making the other his punching bag.

The reason? Raw politics, in the mode of president-elect Donald Trump’s America, because if people trust the CSIRO and accept what it has to say about the poor prospects for nuclear energy in Australia, it means Dutton’s election policy centrepiece is a dud.

Dog-whistling in the dark

We all know this playbook. If you don’t like the message, shoot the messenger. And if the facts don’t suit the case you want to make, scream the room down to get some new ones. The tune being dog-whistled in this case is that when it comes to the nation’s energy transition future, the CSIRO and its regulator collaborator, the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO), are part of our home-grown version of America’s so-called “deep state conspiracy”.

Not that Dutton goes quite that far — suggesting instead that the CSIRO and AEMO, joint authors of the annual GenCost Report, the latest draft of which was released this week — are “bagging” his still-to-be-fully-announced nuclear policy because they are under the “heavy hand” of Labor’s Climate Change and Energy Minister, Chris Bowen. 

So this national science and technology institution, the most trusted of government services, is being politically bullied into sacrificing its independence, rather than simply doing its job? In this case the same job it’s been doing since at least 2018, when the Coalition was the government, evaluating the cost of energy options using a well-understood methodology.

Not that there’s any actual evidence that it is biased, and the CSIRO says the exact opposite, including in a passionate defence from its CEO Doug Hilton earlier this year, after Dutton had claimed its earlier GenCost energy system analysis work, which includes nuclear, had been “discredited”. But don’t let the facts get in the way of some convenient spin.

Still a dud

As the ABC and many others reported on Monday, even after the CSIRO amended its methodology to address last year’s vocal concerns from the pro-nuclear lobby, it still came out as bad news for the Liberal-National Coalition’s nuclear energy investment ambitions, which would be funded from government coffers. 

The ABC report began: “Building a nuclear power plant in Australia would likely cost twice as much as renewable energy even accounting for the much longer life-span of reactors, according to a new report from Australia’s leading science agency.” Specialist energy transition publication Renew Economy reported: “The latest draft version of the CSIRO GenCost report found — as it has done on each and every occasion since 2018 — that integrated wind and solar is by far the cheapest and lowest emissions option for Australia to replace its fleet of ageing, polluting and increasingly unreliable coal generators.”

Renew Economy reports Bowen as saying the latest attack on the CSIRO’s integrity “makes his blood boil”, while professing not to care “two hoots” about the attack on himself. Dutton, meanwhile, leaves others to make more extreme claims.

For example, Dr David Collins, the American-Australian amateur nuclear energy enthusiast who Dutton quoted as an expert multiple times in his landmark nuclear policy speech, dating back to July 7, 2023, where he compared the unqualified Collins’ wild energy transition cost estimates, coming in at a whopping $1.3 trillion, to AEMO’s $383 billion figure.

Collins, who has given evidence to the current parliamentary inquiry into nuclear energy, and recently appeared as a pro-nuke advocate on ABC TV Four Corners, posted on LinkedIn a few weeks ago that:

“We will also need to replace the leadership of CSIRO and Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO), both of whom have exhibited considerable and consistent political bias.”

This pile-on every time the CSIRO touches the nuclear topic is transparently orchestrated, and has clear and obvious echoes from the US and the Trump/MAGA attacks on institutions — such as the Department of Justice (DoJ) and the Center for Disease Control (CDC).

Pitch perfect

Given that it’s now an Australian summer and the cricket is underway, most notably a gripping home Test series between Australian and India, it’s worth recalling how this and other sports stand up for the integrity of their independent officialdom. Dissent against and bad-mouthing umpires is banned, punishable by fines, suspensions, even bans, to protect them in their duties from players, coaches and their camp followers, and even from fans. If only we guarded our great public institutions in similar ways. 

That doesn’t mean having to agree with everything umpires do, or how they do it. Cricket even allows a limited number of in-game team challenges to umpiring decisions, and there are channels for post-match reviews. But out on the field you don’t bring the game, or the institution, into disrepute by loudly questioning its integrity every time a call goes against you.

Politics isn’t cricket, of course, however much we might wish otherwise. But Dutton et al are certainly flooding the field with the proverbial, and may yet find themselves batting on a very sticky wicket.

0 Comments

Subscribe now to the newsletter, delivered to your inbox each day at 4pm