US cock-up adds more awk to AUKUS

How many stuff-ups and insults have to emanate from Trump's White House before politicians and military brass decide it's time to cut and run?

When will Australia’s military brass say enough is enough? 

The question is worth asking again after today’s revelations that Jeffrey Goldberg, editor-in-chief of The Atlantic, was inadvertently included in a chat group discussing White House plans to attack Yemen’s Houthi rebels. The chat took place over a commercially available encrypted app, Signal. It included Vice-President J.D. Vance, Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, National Security Adviser Michael Waltz, and Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard. 

The extraordinary security breach put Hegseth in particular in the firing line. “I don’t know how Pete Hegseth can look service members in the eye,” wrote New York Times columnist David French. “He’s just blown his credibility as a military leader … When you’re careless in the military, people can die. If he had any honor at all, he would resign.” Hegseth? Honour? Resign? Hah! In Donald Trump’s America, you can bet it’s the journalist who gets it in the neck for treason, not the incompetent appointee. And, sure enough, out comes Hegseth describing Goldberg as “deceitful and highly discredited”. No disputing The Atlantic story though, oddly enough. 

Pete, our main man

Hegseth is Australia’s go-to man in Washington for the AUKUS pact. That should make us all feel better. He’s the sort of defence leader you get when the president, in his addled way, likes the way you perform on Fox News. The very same president who acts as an agent for Russia and attacks traditional allies. A national security adviser who spruiks Russian talking points. 

So when is enough enough?  

The really awkward question is whether Australia’s major political parties are capable of drawing any line at all on the US alliance given how invested they are in AUKUS. It might never produce a nuclear submarine for Australia but in its short life it has been a consistently handy plaything, first for the Coalition and then Labor.

No worries. All good

AUKUS was born out of political opportunism when then PM Scott Morrison announced it in the run-up to the 2022 election. And so it has remained. In the shadow of another election, the parties remain on a unity ticket and will keep the pretence going that the alliance is just fine and that there really will be a submarine industry in Australia. Somewhere. Over the rainbow. Fingers and toes crossed.

Whatever its defence value, AUKUS means jobs — even if nothing tangible exists. Earlier this month Defence Minister Richard Marles joined South Australia’s Labor Premier Peter Malinauskas at a sod-turning ceremony for a training academy at Osborne Naval Shipyard near Adelaide. Marles made a pre-election pledge of $500 million to build the skills needed for “Adelaide-built” nuclear-powered submarines. The whole shebang would bring “thousands of well-paid, high-skilled jobs”.  

Over in Perth it’s a similar story. WA’s HMAS Stirling base is undergoing an $8 billion upgrade to prepare for US nuclear-powered submarines under the “submarine rotational force west” program. The upgrade promises around 3,000 jobs over a decade. There are another 3,000 jobs to come at yet-to-be-built maintenance facilities at Henderson, also in West Australia.  

The magic word …

Jobs, jobs, jobs. Votes, votes, votes. Seats, seats, seats. The AUKUS magic pudding works.

For both sides of politics there’s a great deal riding on the idea that Australia will get nuclear submarines and that they will one day be built in Australia. For the ALP the promise of jobs and a new shipbuilding industry has mollified the anti-nuclear concerns of the left of the party and some unions. But what if there are no jobs? What if any future subs are built in the UK or the US because it’s more efficient? How then to run up the white flag?

As former PM Malcolm Turnbull has pointed out lately — and for the umpteenth time — there have always been doubts about the ability of the US to build enough nuclear-powered submarines for its own navy, let alone for Australia. And the US president, whoever it may be, has always had the power of veto. 

Take the hints

Labor has batted away the objections of its elders — Paul Keating, Gareth Evans, Bob Carr (who described AUKUS as ““fragrant, methane-wrapped bullshit”) and Doug Cameron. Less easy to dismiss are the views of retired rear admiral Peter Briggs who concluded last year that halting the AUKUS submarines might be difficult, challenging and politically courageous, “but not nearly as improbable as getting SSNs [nuclear submarines] under AUKUS on time”. He made that call before Trump’s mayhem was unleashed.  

Another former senior naval officer, Chris Barrie, who led the Australian Defence Force from 1998 to 2002, declared that “the vandals in the White House” have pushed the alliance to the brink of irrelevance, and urged the government to reassess its partnership. 

So when is enough enough?

If Australia’s former military insiders are sounding the alarm, maybe it’s time for self-interested politicians to listen and act. 

38 Comments

  1. “…For the ALP the promise of jobs and a new shipbuilding industry has mollified the anti-nuclear concerns of the left of the party and some unions…”

    Don’t you believe it!

    • DAVID HARDAKER

      Do elaborate!

      • Labor Against War (LAW) is advocating the cancellation of AUKUS. We don’t need forever uranium waste; we don’t need submarines designed to stay under for lengthy periods (I recently heard 102 days…yikes!). Sure, we need a defence policy which is based on who might attack us and how…and when. AUKUS is not that policy.

        • Ps. There are good jobs, and bad jobs.

    • David, thank you again for a great article. Any thinking, intelligent Aust’n would have been horrified by the announcement of AUKUS. Signed off by Morriscum & quickly followed by Albo. Not a good look Albo!!! Not happy at all with the result Albo, what is the positive in this for the Australian people? $368 bill would go a long way to building ‘social housing’, to supporting disabled ppl, those on pensions/payments. I don’t expect miracles, but I would like to think that we do have Australians that are intelligent, accepting, caring individuals. The jury is still out on that in my mind. Cheers David, xo

      • Correct Marilyn. Morrison and Trump two of a kind, seldom truth bound, very ego driven and more about selves than Country and wise choices. $368 Billion, plus and we are very likely never to see a Sub, let alone have control over what unwisely pay for. Fighter Jets, Drones and our own made warships are a smarter option, and if subs are a need then those from France, or Japan would better, quicker to receive and with our own control. The sooner we break with unstable and und reliable USA the better. Trump is a willing Puppet of Putin, and dreams to be like. Ego driven and controlling. Australia needs a new Leader desperately, and it is certainly not Albo or Dutton, Both main Parties have far better choices that show more Intelligence, integrity with displayed good planning, broad consultation and progressive Judgement. I follow Politics and listen keenly to what each say and do, so have developed reasonable choices for a Credible Leader, from worthy Achievers in Ministers and Premiers included. I am looking for change soon and hopefully see it come for this Country and our peoples sake.

  2. A bit like extracting oneself from an abusive relationship. You’ve invested so much time and energy (and in this case money) and it’s hard to admit that you’ve made a mistake, that you’ve failed. But sooner or later it must be done. A relationship with Trump et al is an abusive relationship and I fear we will pay a hefty price if we stay.

    • 6 billion for 3 thousand jobs- what a bargain.
      But of course we all know it’s going to be a lot more for a lot less

      • There’s a strong case for a Universal Basic Income if there ever was one!

    • Touche

    • Sounds pretty much like the cosy relationship between Labor & the CFMEU in Victoria, with the MASSIVE cost blowouts of the useless SRL East & the NE Link virtually bankrupting the State, but Premier Allan is too proud to admit it’s a dead duck walking whilst the rest of the State crumbles.

      • Vote for the Greens. Problem solved

    • Sunk costs! Just walk away!

  3. Under the circumstances I think that we can expect more of the same, especially with so many rank amateurs whose fealty is to Trump!

    Nothing but a huge man baby spitting the dummy at anything and everything.

  4. Yes, Aukus was at best a huge piece of political opportunism. The sooner we drop it, the better from every point of view. At the moment, we’re just tipping vast amounts of money into a dark, and apparently bottomless, hole. There’s no guarantee we’ll get anything out of the deal apart from a huge budget hit, and there’s certainly no surety that we’ll ever see a rubber ducky, let alone any submarines.

  5. We should go to the French and say look, we are sorry we fucked it up last time. Here is a bucket of cash. Give us one of your nice shiny nuclear boats, and give us the IP so that we can build some for ourselves.

    Then sit on the navy to not add stupid stuff to the contract.

    And with the money saved on AKUS start to build surface and autonomous assets as well.

    Trump has demonstrated that he will act in the extremely short term to get what he wants. for example dening intelligence to Ukraine. But adding assets like ships or submarines is a very long term project. America has demonstrated that it is out of the long term business, and is completely unreliable. We need to find the partners that are reliable and will be with us long term.

  6. This whole package of sub sh!t makes me seasick. Get rid of this bottomless money box brainfart of a Scumo idea now.
    Invest in razor blades instead, cos that’s where these subs will end up.

  7. I’m looking forward to catching very fast train to the Australian nuclear powered submarine manufacturing facility!!

  8. Maybe the ALP and LNP are frightened of pulling out of AUKUS? I mean Japan was shitty as we failed to contract them to build our subs. But they are very polite. France was shitty when we pulled out of our contract. They definitely expressed anger in a Gallic way. But they’re harmless. Pull out of AUKUS? The USA will be furious, righteous and unpredictable. I wouldn’t like to be the one to tell the USA we’re pulling out of the contract. We’ve made our bed and now we have to sleep in it.

    • So what Mark? We continue to hand over billions for something almost everyone agrees we will never see? Nuclear subs? I agree that there would be risks in telling the US we no longer want to be part of their boondoggle but since trump seems to want to pull out of wars he’s ( perhaps ) unlikely to think that’s worth invading Australia for.

  9. I agree with both David Clark and Mark Williamson. We need to cut our losses with the yanks, because I can’t see Trump giving us our money back, but we can try. We do need to go back to the French, crawl if we have to, and see if they will sell us one of their subs. It makes sense to work with them, long term, rather than with “short term” Trump and Hegseth especially after recent events in the US.

    We need the money more than America and we can use the funds better once they are back in our control.

    If it is decided to stay with the US then we can request basic nuclear submarines and we will do the fit out ourselves.

    My immediate decision would be to cancel the US order and get our money back. If they don’t like it too bad!

  10. Postpone, postpone, postpone… At least till the mid-terms. If we (and the rest of the world) are lucky enough to find the bulk of the US population have realised they have fallen for this grift we may see a Congress and Senate ready to impeach the Orange Peril

    • DAVID HARDAKER

      Phil, I wish I could share your optimism but I fear the bulk of the US population – or enough of them – will go along with the grift. I can’t imagine what could make them change… it’s alarming!

      • Doesn’t matter what the US voters want, after the Republicans are finished with their gerrymandering and Voter suppression, as Trump said “you won’t ever have to vote again” !

  11. We must remember that two of the architects of this deal were Scott Morrison and Boris Johnson. Enough said.

  12. I’m disgusted with the craven gutlessness of the ALP over this whole mess
    FFS it was a Morrison brain fart
    That alone should have warned them off
    but it is embraced as if it was holy writ
    I despair
    I can’t vote LNP or Greens so I may as well rip up my ballot paper

    WTF are they thinking

    • Agree with everything you say except your voting conclusion. Why can’t you vote Green? If you have a Green or credible independent vote for them but make sure you put the LNP stone last.

  13. Awkus is a dud. The political class need to show some initiative and transition to modern defence systems like the very successful air and sea drones used by Ukraine. Use the Awkus money for a smart sophisticated defence industry capable of defending our island. (Before we sell it all to oligarchs of course).

  14. When Australia tried to invoke ANZUS over both the imperialistic Indonesian occupation of West Papua, and the Indonesian imperialist/genocidal occupation of Timor Leste, the results from both Kennedy and Clinton were long drawn-out yawns. So in fact, ANZUS isn’t the paper it is printed on, and in fact is really only a consultative mechanism, and not a binding military treaty, and has been only used to drag Australia and Aotearoa into US imperialist adventures to protect US capitalist and imperialist interests against people that are no threat to us, and wish us no harm, such as the Vietnamese, Iraqis and Afghanistanis. I suspect the AUKUS will be the same, against people who are no threat to us and wish us no harm.

    • The AUKUS debacle is just that, no matter which party is in government (in the US) they’re struggling to build enough submarines for themselves, the French submarine plan had some merit but our specific requirements were pretty were over the top, we want a nuclear submarine that isn’t nuclear! Another factor that seems to be overlooked is the submarines we have at the moment, out of the 6, 2 were used as spare parts for the other 4, mind you this is fairly old data but the reasons behind this were mainly the lack of personnel to man them, unless we have huge influx of naval recruits busting to become submariners the next generation of submarines is destined to go the same way.

  15. When Australia tried to invoke ANZUS over both the imperialistic Indonesian occupation of West Papua, and the Indonesian imperialist/genocidal occupation of Timor Leste, the results from both Kennedy and Clinton were long drawn-out yawns. So in fact, ANZUS isn’t the paper it is printed on, and in fact is really only a consultative mechanism, and not a binding military treaty, and has been only used to drag Australia and Aotearoa into US imperialist adventures to protect US capitalist and imperialist interests against people that are no threat to us, and wish us no harm, such as the Vietnamese, Iraqis and Afghanistanis. I suspect the AUKUS will be the same, against people who are no threat to us and wish us no harm.

  16. There are plenty of jobs in AUKUS!! Pity they are only for the Ex-MP grifters. (Hockey, Morrison, Pine, the Labor MPs will join the public funded gravy train in due course)

  17. The AUKUS rort is the biggest rort Australia has seen to date by far. Driven presumably by the shady ‘security cluster’. There’s little doubt that the international arms trade is the world’s biggest crime syndicate and seems to have the Australian government and foreign policy direction firmly in its claws. As if there aren’t real issues we should be focusing on.

  18. There is no speculation about the possible consequences of leaving, I believe the orange one would impose impossible ones.

  19. as a West Australian I am furious the base is on our doorstep, literally, so a sitting target. NO ONE asked if we wanted. No discussion or options to move to less populated areas. Just a deal with State Govt, jobs, naval base expansion etc etc. AND no discussion about where waste will be kept. I remember when NZ banned nuclear totally (including naval) while Aust just banned mining of uranium that Gina is now pushing to reopen, cos of course she has interests to add to her groaning coffers, while her family dwindles further away.

  20. Have you ever considered about adding a little bit more than just your articles?
    I mean, what you say is important and all. But imagine if
    you added some great images or videos to give your posts more,
    “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and clips, this website could definitely be one
    of the greatest in its field. Wonderful blog!

  21. No imagery needed. Your excellent article more than enough.
    As for AUKUS I believe the US is far too unstable and we should be supporting Europe. France. We shouldn’t be supporting the US to sell out Ukraine and Palestine. We need to be reducing our dependency on them.
    We should listen to the likes of Malcolm Turnbull and Chris Barrie and Peter Briggs. A total re think.

Subscribe now to the newsletter, delivered to your inbox each day at 4pm